The best best my little pony toys is the Toy Rainbow Equestria Favorites 10 Figure Collection. It gives you the biggest cast of main characters in one box, which makes it the obvious pick for any kid who loves the show or wants to start a proper collection. If you want a smaller set that focuses on the newest generation of ponies instead, the Toys Make Your Mark Collection 5 is a great alternative with a fresh lineup.
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
This guide breaks down five different My Little Pony sets by the number of figures, the size of the ponies, and what kind of play they encourage. I also cover who should skip this category entirely. If you are looking for a craft activity or a single large doll, you will find your answer in the Who Should NOT Buy section.
Everything below comes from current Amazon product data, manufacturer specs, and each product's owner track record. I have not physically tested these toys myself.
Quick Answer: The Best My Little Pony Toys
The Toy Rainbow Equestria Favorites 10 Figure Collection is the best overall pick for most families because it packs ten main characters into one affordable set.
- Toy Rainbow Equestria Favorites 10 Figure (Best for complete cast collection): Ten classic ponies in one box including Twilight Sparkle, Rainbow Dash, and Pinkie Pie.
- Toys Make Your Mark Collection 5 (Best for newest generation fans): Five 3-inch figures from the latest Make Your Mark series.
- My Little Pony Tell Your Tale (Best for interactive hair styling): A 9.5-inch Izzy Moonbow figure with sound effects and real styling action.
- Dolls Rainbow Celebration 6 Pony Figure (Best for budget variety pack): Six 5.5-inch ponies at a very low per-figure cost.
- Play-Doh Make & Style Ponies (Best for arts and crafts fans): A creative playset that combines pony figures with Play-Doh styling tools.
Thinking about a single large doll or a craft project instead? Jump to Who Should NOT Buy below before you spend anything.
Comparison Table
Here is the lineup at a glance: photo, product, who it is built for, and our /10 score.
| Photo | Product | Best for | Score | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|
 | Toy Rainbow Equestria Favorites 10 Figure | Complete cast collection | 9.1/10 | Check price → |
 | Toys Make Your Mark Collection 5 | Newest generation fans | 8.8/10 | Check price → |
 | My Little Pony Tell Your Tale | Interactive hair styling | 8.5/10 | Check price → |
 | Dolls Rainbow Celebration 6 Pony Figure | Budget variety pack | 8.2/10 | Check price → |
 | Play-Doh Make & Style Ponies | Arts and crafts fans | 7.9/10 | Check price → |
Scroll sideways on small screens to see every column.
Toy Rainbow Equestria Favorites 10 Figure: Best Overall for Most Families
Toys Make Your Mark Collection 5: Best for New Generation Fans
My Little Pony Tell Your Tale: Best for Interactive Play
Dolls Rainbow Celebration 6 Pony Figure: Best Budget Variety Pack
Play-Doh Make & Style Ponies: Best for Arts and Crafts Fans
Buying Guide: Number of Figures, Size, Play Style, and Budget
Choosing the right My Little Pony set comes down to four simple factors. Understanding these will help you pick the one that best matches your child's play habits and your expectations.
How Many Figures Do You Really Need?
The first decision is about quantity. The sets in this guide range from 2 figures to 10 figures. A larger set like the Toy Rainbow Equestria Favorites 10 Figure gives you an instant collection that supports group storytelling and playdates.
You do not need to buy multiple packs to get a full cast. Smaller sets like the Play-Doh Make & Style Ponies only include two figures, which limits the scenarios a child can create. If your child likes to act out scenes with multiple characters, aim for a set with at least five or six figures.
For young children who are just starting to play with ponies, a smaller set can be less overwhelming.
What Size Figure Is Best for Your Child?
Figure size affects how easy the toy is to handle and where it can be played with. The 3-inch figures in the Equestria Favorites and Make Your Mark sets are small and portable. They fit in playsets, pockets, and small carry bags.
The 5.5-inch figures in the Rainbow Celebration set are a good middle ground. They are easier for toddlers to hold but still fit in most playsets. The 9.5-inch Tell Your Tale doll is a standalone toy.
It is too big for most playsets but offers a more substantial feel and better hair styling opportunities. Consider your child's age and dexterity. Younger kids generally do better with larger figures that are harder to swallow and easier to grip.
What Kind of Play Does Your Child Prefer?
Not all pony toys encourage the same type of play. Static figure sets like the Equestria Favorites and Make Your Mark are best for imaginative storytelling and collecting. They are great for kids who love to create scenes and act out episodes.
The Tell Your Tale doll adds an interactive element with sound effects and hair styling, which appeals to kids who enjoy dressing up and grooming toys. The Play-Doh set is a craft activity first and a pony toy second. It is ideal for children who love arts and crafts and want a creative outlet.
Think about whether your child prefers open-ended storytelling, sensory play, or creative construction.
How Much Should You Spend on a Set?
The sets in this guide span a range of price points. The Rainbow Celebration 6 Pony Figure set offers the best value if you want a decent number of figures at a low per-doll cost. The Equestria Favorites 10 Figure set costs more upfront but gives you the most figures per dollar.
The Tell Your Tale doll and the Play-Doh set are priced differently because they include interactive features or craft supplies. A good rule of thumb is to consider the cost per figure. If you want a large collection quickly, a multi-figure set is almost always more economical than buying individual figures one at a time.
Who Should NOT Buy Best My Little Pony Toys
My Little Pony toys are not the right purchase for every child or every situation. Here are three types of buyers who should look at different categories instead.
You Need a Quiet, Screen-Free Activity
If your goal is to keep a child busy with a quiet, hands-on activity that does not involve screens, a standard pony figure set might not be the best choice. The figures are meant for imaginative play, which requires active engagement. Some children lose interest in static figures after a short time.
Look for a creative playset like the Play-Doh Make & Style Ponies, which combines crafting with pony play. Alternatively, consider a puzzle, a building set, or a coloring book that offers more structured activity.
You Want a Toy That Encourages Solo Quiet Play
My Little Pony toys are naturally social. They work best when a child is playing with others or has a vivid imagination for solo storytelling. Some children prefer toys that are more solitary and calming, such as sensory toys, fidget toys, or simple building blocks.
If your child does not naturally engage in pretend play with figures, a pony set could end up collecting dust. Consider a personalised wooden toy box to store the toys they already love, or look for a Montessori-style educational toy that encourages focused solo play.
You Are Looking for a Collectible Investment
Some collectors buy toys hoping they will increase in value over time. My Little Pony toys from the current generation are mass-produced and are not likely to become rare collectibles. They are designed for play, not for display in a sealed box.
If you are looking for an investment piece, look for limited edition releases, vintage toys in original packaging, or licensed collectibles from specialty brands. For everyday play, these sets are excellent. For long-term value, they are not the right choice.
Final Verdict
The Toy Rainbow Equestria Favorites 10 Figure is the best overall pick for most families. It gives you the most characters for your money, covers the main cast from the classic show, and has a solid build quality that holds up to daily play. If your child loves the newer Make Your Mark series, the Toys Make Your Mark Collection 5 is a faithful set with excellent detail.
Need a single large doll with styling features? The My Little Pony Tell Your Tale offers sound effects and hair styling in a big 9.5-inch package. On a tight budget?
The Dolls Rainbow Celebration 6 Pony Figure gives you six figures at a very competitive price. And for a creative craft activity, the Play-Doh Make & Style Ponies combines pony play with hands-on fun.
If you are still unsure, re-read the buying guide above and think about what kind of play your child enjoys most. And if none of these fit, check the Who Should NOT Buy section for alternative categories.
FAQ
What is the best My Little Pony toy overall?
The Toy Rainbow Equestria Favorites 10 Figure Collection is the best overall pick. It includes ten main characters from the classic Friendship is Magic series, offers great value for the number of figures, and has a 4.8 out of 5 star rating from verified buyers.
Are My Little Pony toys safe for 2 year olds?
The manufacturer recommends these toys for ages 3 and up. The smaller 3-inch figures can be a choking hazard for children under 3. Always check the age recommendation on the box.
The 5.5-inch and 9.5-inch figures are larger and may be safer for younger toddlers under supervision.
Which My Little Pony set has the most figures?
The Toy Rainbow Equestria Favorites 10 Figure Collection has the most figures in this guide with ten ponies. The Dolls Rainbow Celebration 6 Pony Figure set is the next largest with six figures.
Do any of these ponies have moving parts or articulation?
None of the figure sets in this guide have poseable joints. The figures are static. The My Little Pony Tell Your Tale doll has a sound button that activates phrases, but the body itself does not move.
The Play-Doh set has tools for styling hair but no articulation.
What is the difference between the classic and new generation ponies?
The classic ponies are from the Friendship is Magic series that ran from 2010 to 2020. The new generation ponies are from the Make Your Mark series that started in 2022. The designs are slightly different, with the new generation having larger eyes and a more modern art style.
The Equestria Favorites set is classic. The Make Your Mark and Rainbow Celebration sets are new generation.